Pope Francis Sets Up A Straw Man: There Are No Closed Doors To Repentant Reverts and Converts

Pope Fancis made a righteous appeal on Saint Patrick’s Day that no one in the Church should close the door to someone who is responding to the call of the Holy Spirit to come back to the Church.  Those who would pose obstacles to these reverts are sinning and are akin to the Pharisees who scolded Jesus for healing on the Sabbath.  I agree completely, if this actually happened anywhere in the world.  The problem is that this doesn’t happen in normal parishes.  I have never heard a priest or layman say that sinners coming back after a long time away, maybe even with decades of sin clinging to them, should not be allowed to come worship at the Mass or take part in any other parish activity.  In fact, had we heard of such a thing, there would be such an outrage that it wouldn’t be permitted.

Unfortunately, the Pontiff is setting up a straw man to knock down, in his transparent slap at those who insist that the dogmas of the Faith should not be denied by permitting those in unrepentant and unabsolved mortal sin to receive the Eucharist.  He equates the adherence to and full practice of the Faith to the Pharisees that scold Jesus for healing on the Sabbath, which is an inapt comparison.

The pope, almost even completely coherently and passionately shows his ire for those who would close the door to such repentant people.  “Who are you, who shut your door to the heart of a man, a woman who wants to improve, to get back into the people of God, because the Holy Spirit has stirred his heart.”

Using the imagery of water from both readings, the pope spoke of men and women who may have made mistakes in their lives but now feel “that the waters are moving” and they want to come back to the Christian community.

“And how many times today in Christian communities [they] find closed doors: ‘But you cannot, no, you cannot,'” said the pope, imitating someone who prevents such people from reentering the community.

“‘You have done wrong here and you cannot,'” Francis continued the imitation. “‘If you want to come, come to Mass on Sunday, but stay there, but do not do more.'”

Summing up how he feels about such a situation, the pontiff said: “That which the Holy Spirit does in the hearts of people, Christians with the psychology of doctors of the law destroy.”

None of us sees anyone blocking the doors to the Church when a repentant sinner comes home.  No one sees or hears anyone scold such a person when they seek to come home.  None ever hears a priest say that such people are unwelcome. Yet, this fiction is trotted out as a real problem in the Church today by the pope.  Is this the right way to start off the much ballyhooed Jubilee Year of Mercy for next year?  Is this the premise on which this celebration will be based?  Is it proper to base this on a contrived nonexistent “problem”?

I was once a man such as he described.  When I had my moment that instantaneously gave me the gift of Faith, where I knew God is real after decades away, I came back to the Church.  That first Sunday, I walked into the Church without anyone barring the door, or refusing me a seat.  I was called back and I wanted to be back with God.  Foolishly, I thought then that I needed to receive the Eucharist as part of my rebirth.  I did.  I did again the next week.  The third Sunday at Communion time, I stayed in the pew, as if fixed there with a clear understanding that I was not to receive the Eucharist without first making my confession.  I spent the next week scolding myself for being so stupid about receiving the Eucharist while in mortal sin, for being so stupid for forgetting this, and then examining my conscience as I prepared to make my first confession in nearly thirty years.

What I needed then was someone to remind me of what I had forgotten, to remind me of the danger to myself to receive the Eucharist unworthily.  The Holy Spirit led me back and then the Holy Spirit prevented me from committing sacrilege continuously.  I went to confession the next Saturday, with much trepidation, and much disgust for all the sins I had committed, and with great shame.  It was one of the best days in my life as it turned out.  The sheer sense of overwhelming lightness and joy stayed with me for weeks, and it was most beautiful when I approached and received Holy Communion again in a state of grace for the first time since my early teen years.

At the same time, I also needed to decide whether I was going to be a Catholic or not, and I knew that I did not have the option to pick and choose which dogmas I would accept and abide by and those I wouldn’t.  Either I was all in or I had to go somewhere else.  I reflected on this for some time and then it came to me: who am I to say that I know better than the Church, that I am so much smarter than the saints, known and unknown, who had come before me, who had prayed and studied and received the sacraments?  It was then I knew that I had to change my life and that the Church does not change to suit me.  I became determined to learn the Faith again, and what I did not “feel” was acceptable I decided that I had to make a better effort to understand why the Church teaches as She does.  I challenged myself by forcing myself to accept the proposition that if I disagree with a dogma of the Faith, I must figure out, not where the Church has gone wrong in the teaching, but where I had gone wrong in my understanding.  Since then, I have always found where I was wrong, and I have found the Church to be right every time.

The dogmas and the practice of the Faith are not unmerciful.  They are liberating.  This is what those reverts that Pope Francis refers to really need to know and understand, and this is the message they need to hear and to also accept fully.  To permit these people who are in the state I was to receive the Eucharist without repentance and absolution after a good confession is a great injustice, to them, the Church, and to Jesus.  In his homily, the pope should have spoken of these necessary truthful corollaries to what he said.

When I came back, I did not believe the Church and the Faith were hurtful or mean to me.  What I needed and what I got were an open door to worship, but also the greatest opportunity to repent, confess my sins, and be absolved, and then to become once again in full communion in a state of grace.  To make that confession was painful and stressful, until I sat in the confessional.  But that pain and stress was necessary for me, and it is necessary for anyone and even more so for those who have been away for a long time and who are brought back by the Holy Spirit.  In the examination period before, in the confessional, and then thereafter as prayers and tears of thanksgiving are offered, that is where each one of us comes to understand mercy.  Far from being “mean”, “unmerciful” or “unwelcoming”, it is the most profound and cathartic experience that leads to true healing.  That’s what people need to know and experience, and not the counterfeit faith offered by Cardinals Marx and Kasper and Tagle and even the pope.

Posted in Faith, Family, Life, Parish Life, Pope Francis the Muddle-Headed?, Profaning the Eucharist or Trying To, The Mass, The Point of The Blog
5 comments on “Pope Francis Sets Up A Straw Man: There Are No Closed Doors To Repentant Reverts and Converts
  1. S. Armaticus says:

    Hi Steve,

    Had a great idea. Maybe those “meet and greet” groups that hang out at the back of the churches can be transformed into “meet and ‘splain the rules” groups to anyone who is returning to the fold and wants to do it properly.

    Maybe these folks should be given a special name like “eucharistic ‘splainers”.

    Come to think of it, why did the VII types set up these groups in the first place?


    Liked by 1 person

  2. Tamsin says:

    The rhetorical use of “strawmen” reminds me…

    There seem to be a lot of parallels between how Team Obama has operated, with the help of media to try to finish a fundamental transformation of the country, and how Team Bergoglio is operating with the help of media to try to finish a fundamental transformation of the Church.

    Obama sets aside plain meanings of our written Constitution. People are discouraged from deducing practices from Constitutional principles.

    The media participate in this fundamental transformation by reporting on his executive actions as though the president was not an administrator, but was the supreme legislator: the only person elected by all the people, the sole arbiter of our common good, the right man to write the laws.

    Likewise, the pope proposes new practices under cover of mercy. Practices that set aside plain meanings of our written doctrines.

    Written down, for crying out loud. For Christ’s sake.

    In the US, I thought we had rule of law, not men (this man, that man, the next man: whoever has seized power next). In the Church, I thought we had rule of Logos, not men.

    The demogoguery is disappointing.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Recent Posts

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Pesky Truth

Political News, Commentary and Humor

New York Post

Your source for breaking news, news about New York, sports, business, entertainment, opinion, real estate, culture, fashion, and more.

Big Picture News, Informed Analysis

This blog is written by Canadian journalist Donna Laframboise. Posts appear Monday, Wednesday & Friday.

Tedium: The Dull Side of the Internet.

Latin For OUT OF GREAT SILENCE: An Orthodox Traditional Modern Catholic Layman's Perspective

The Catholic Gentleman

A blog for Catholic men that seeks to encourage virtue, the pursuit of holiness and the art of true masculinity.


Taking small steps each day to become a little healthier

C.J.'s Roku World

Roku for beginner's

Frugal Fixes

Fixes that save money and sometimes even the environment.

Tech Halfpipe

Over 20 years working with technology and that I'm also a geek at home, as a personal distraction, I thought I would share some the tech solutions and challenges that I come across, and hopefully some solutions. Also will share some of the exciting things going on with STEM and the education of our youth

Archived Innings

An exploration of the National Pastime

The Baseball Bloggess

Loves the 4-6-3 and the Serial Comma.

Race Communications Blog

Follow our blog for a more in-depth look at our fiber projects across California.

POTs and PANs

Pretty Advanced New Stuff from CCG Consulting

Nickels, Dimes and Quarters


The Minimalists Next Door

Living simply, frugally, and intentionally


Entrepreneur, Speaker, Author


Moving To A 21st Century Entertainment Paradigm

Lefthanded Conservative

I'm left-handed, although my views are on the right

Credo Sanctum

Following the Apostolic Fatih

non veni pacem

The Splendor of Truth


Surprising contributions by Francis to the Magisterium...

Maureen Mullarkey: Studio Matters

Latin For OUT OF GREAT SILENCE: An Orthodox Traditional Modern Catholic Layman's Perspective

Real Science

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" - Richard Feynman

Our Game

Official Blog of MLB Historian John Thorn

The Hardball Times

Latin For OUT OF GREAT SILENCE: An Orthodox Traditional Modern Catholic Layman's Perspective

FanGraphs Baseball

Latin For OUT OF GREAT SILENCE: An Orthodox Traditional Modern Catholic Layman's Perspective

One Mad Mom

Crazy? Angry? You decide and I really don't care!


Latin For OUT OF GREAT SILENCE: An Orthodox Traditional Modern Catholic Layman's Perspective

Athanasius Contra Mundum

A website for Catholic Theology, Tradition, and Opposition to an insane world.

Quartermaster of the Barque

Dispensing Orthodox Catholic Joy!

LI & NY Places that are no more

A fun look back at history by Todd Berkun

Mahound's Paradise

Latin For OUT OF GREAT SILENCE: An Orthodox Traditional Modern Catholic Layman's Perspective


An online journal edited by the Slaves of the Immaculate Heart of Mary, Richmond N.H.

Pauliebronx's Blog

Just another WordPress.com site

The Catholic Husband

24 Years Happily Married and Counting...

The Counter Jihad Report

News ~ Resources ~ Activism

The Stumbling Block

There's nothing good or Catholic about liberalism

Seeking Justice

Latin For OUT OF GREAT SILENCE: An Orthodox Traditional Modern Catholic Layman's Perspective

My Path to Faith

"We ought to make some progress, however little, every day, and show some increase of fervor. We ought to act as if we were at war as, indeed, we are and never relax until we have won the victory." St. Teresa of Ávila

Ponder Anew

Thinking about matters in life and faith and how reason puts it all together....

Notes From The Battleground

Working Out Our Salvation With Fear and Trembling

%d bloggers like this: